Faith on Trial: When Truth and Evidence Take the Stand, the System Starts Sweating
When you take the witness stand in a court of law, you put your hand on the Bible and swear to tell the truth. Isn’t that something? Now, imagine taking that Bible and building a case around it as a Defendant. Jesus, recognized by Christians as the way, the truth and the life is on trial as a defendant and the Bible is the evidence his attorney introduces into the trial.
Imagine that.
Daniel Buttafuoco, a respected and successful trial attorney, is ready to bring a courtroom lens to the most important question ever asked: Is Christianity true? And he makes the case with the same tools that persuade juries every day in American courts—evidence, eyewitness testimony, corroborating accounts, and contemporaneous documentation. The result is a razor-sharp, courtroom-grade argument that flips the script on secular skepticism: if Christianity were put on trial today, Christians would win.
Buttafuoco explains that in any courtroom, contemporaneous notes—written accounts produced close to the events—are considered among the strongest forms of evidence. In criminal investigations, for example, FBI agents and investigators write notes during their interviews and then type them up in a separate, more contextualized document.
That’s what the Bible is!
Such contemporaneous notes and written testimony is admitted every day in cases involving contracts, criminal investigations, medical records, and witness statements. By that standard alone, the Bible is not a vague spiritual text; it is an extensive, multi-author evidentiary record spanning centuries, cultures, and historical events. Each book functions as another piece of testimony. Each author serves as another witness. Each page contributes to a chain of custody that strengthens, rather than weakens, the case.
The Gospels, Buttafuoco notes, are particularly unignorable. They are eyewitness accounts, corroborating one another through consistent narrative, independent sourcing, and detail specificity—features that trial lawyers immediately recognize as hallmarks of credible testimony. In any modern trial, multiple eyewitnesses describing the same events with overlapping precision is considered a prosecution’s dream scenario. Skeptics demand “evidence,” but if these accounts were anything other than Scripture—say, four witnesses describing a crime scene—no jury in America would dismiss them.
So, what would happen if Christianity were formally put on trial in 2025? Under standard rules of jurisprudence, the Bible itself would have to be admitted as evidence. Not as poetry. Not as mythology. But as documented testimony, supported by historical context, external corroboration, and manuscript reliability unparalleled in ancient literature. Once admitted, the verdict writes itself: the defense wins.
Buttafuoco isn’t arguing for blind faith. He’s arguing for evidentiary faith—the kind built on proof, eyewitnesses, and the same standards that convict criminals and settle billion-dollar disputes. His message is modern, legal, unapologetic, and designed for an America increasingly hungry for certainty in uncertain times.
Daniel Buttafuoco is available now for television, radio, podcasts, print, and long-form interviews. His courtroom approach to Scripture delivers a fresh, compelling, and unbeatable case for the legitimacy of Christianity.
OPTIONAL Q&A:
- How does Daniel Buttafuoco apply modern rules of evidence to the Bible itself?
- Why are contemporaneous notes considered so powerful in court, and how does Scripture fit that standard?
- If the Gospels qualify as eyewitness testimony, what does that mean for Christianity’s credibility?
- Would any modern jury be allowed to dismiss multi-witness accounts the way skeptics dismiss Scripture?
- How does the Bible’s manuscript record compare to other ancient documents routinely accepted as historical fact?
- If Christianity were put on trial today, what evidence would Buttafuoco submit first—and why?
- Why do skeptics demand courtroom-level proof yet reject courtroom-approved evidence when it comes to faith?
- What would the verdict be if a real judge applied standard jurisprudence to the claims of Christianity?
- Can you tell us about a lesser-known part of your backstory that might surprise people?
- Who or what has been your strongest support system along the way, and how did it shape your journey?
- Who has had the biggest influence on your journey, and what’s the most important lesson they taught you?
- Can you share one bold risk you took that opened the door to a major milestone?
- What daily habits or practices helped you stay consistent and focused?
- How do you personally measure success beyond titles, awards, or financial gain?
- If you could sum up your guiding philosophy or mindset in one sentence, what would it be?
Relevant Article(s)
ABOUT DANIEL P. BUTTAFUOCO…
Daniel P. Buttafuoco, Esq., B.A., J.D., M.A. (Theology) is a distinguished trial attorney and Christian apologist who has built a formidable legal legacy alongside his work defending the faith. Over the course of his career, his personal-injury law firm has recovered more than $750 million for injured clients across the nation. His courtroom skill has earned him multiple Best Lawyer honors, and he has been named a Super Lawyer—a designation awarded to the top 5% of attorneys nationwide.
Buttafuoco’s legal success is matched by his passion for biblical scholarship. He holds a Master’s in Theology, and he founded the Historical Bible Society with a mission to preserve and study ancient biblical texts. His courtroom precision informs his approach to Christian apologetics: he treats historical and scriptural evidence with the same rigor he applied to legal cases.
As an author, his books—including Consider the Evidence: A Trial Lawyer Examines Eyewitness Testimony in Defense of the Reliability of the New Testament and Unapologetic: Clear Answers to Tough Bible Questions—draw on his legal instincts to present reasoned, accessible defenses for the Christian faith. Through public speaking, radio appearances, and traveling exhibits of ancient manuscripts, Buttafuoco empowers believers and skeptics alike to explore faith through the lens of evidence and truth.
TO SCHEDULE INTERVIEW, CALL OR TEXT 512-966-0983 / EMAIL BOOKINGS@SPECIALGUESTS.COM
